I don’t really know how I found my faith. Looking back it all seems like a three ring circus but somehow, I made it through. IntroIn an effort to better acquaint you, the reader, with a bit of my history, I think it would be wise to begin with a touch of education, specifically, a brief survey in regards to the Christian sub-culture. My wife doesn’t understand Christian sub-culture. Her upbringing was Catholic and just for clarification, that’s not a slick way of saying “before she was saved.” It’s an odd thing since most world religions really haven’t learned how to shape their belief system into a multi-billion dollar marketing juggernaut. As far as I know there are no lines of Hindu-wear, no Buddhist skate nights or Muslim Discount Days at Six Flags. I suppose none of this is news to anyone but if you will forgive my indulgence here, it might do some good to go over a few highlights. So this is sort of a primer on Christian Rock.
Somebody’s Gonna Praise His NameThe foundation of the Prairie Capital Convention Center is shaking as the subs buried beneath the stage assault the very core of 6,500 teenagers gathered here to rock out...and oddly enough, their parents as well. It's November 1991 and I am standing in awe of the spectacle before me. The lead singer is running back and forth to opposite ends of the stage, his mane of wildly unkempt hair bathed in blue light. He wears an over-sized, white pirate shirt complete with purple spandex that are tucked into suede cowboy boots. The keyboard and bass players share an equal taste in style as well as hairspray. As for the lead guitarist, he appears a good ten years older than the rest of the band, comfortable in his leather vest, acid-washed blue jeans, and semi-permed micro-mullet. Lead singer John turns to the smiling drummer, happy in his signature Mickey Mouse muscle t-shirt, and asks, "HEY LOUIE, IS IT GONNA BE YOU?" With this, Louie Weaver, long-time drummer for Petra, launches into his time-honored traditional drum solo of praise as the band riffs through the fan favorite, "Somebody's Gonna Praise His Name."

I am 12 years old and this is my first Petra concert. Though the scene is at least reminiscent of a show by Warrant that took place at this very location only weeks earlier, the spirit of tonight’s event is quite different. Though the occasional whiff of cigarette smoke is evident, possibly the result of a misguided roadie or an unsaved friend, the usual aromas of weed and overpriced beer are strangely absent. As one would expect, the arena is full of teenage boys in logo-heavy black t-shirts. What is missing are the usual wardrobe tributes to Metallica, Guns N Roses and Bon Jovi. Most are gimmicky knock offs of popular advertising giants such as Coca-Cola (Jesus: Eternally Refreshing), Jack Daniels (Daniel and the Lions Den) and Gold’s Gym (the infamously awkward Lord’s Gym featuring a fallen image of Christ in the push-up position with a rugged cross on his back labeled “sin of the world.” The t-shirt challenges the bewildered gawker to “bench-press this.” ) Also missing from the scene are the hundreds of “rock sign” hand gestures typically associated with any rock show. A few well meaning concert goers make a less than successful attempt and wind up displaying the “I love you” sign while most in attendance, likely heeding a warning against Satan worship inspired by Jack Chick, prefer the simplicity of “one way.” Throughout the night, lead singer John encourages his audience to clap their hands for Jesus, a tradition that will eventually be commonly referred to as a “clap offering.” Occasional random shouts of “JESUS” are encouraged as well. About an hour in, the band exits the stage, leaving only their leader to stand in a single spotlight. He begins to talk in a more reserved tone about the band’s real purpose for being there that evening. In addition to rocking out, their main mission is to glorify Jesus Christ and through their music, bring people to Him. This segue ways into about a 20 minute sermon, culminating in an actual altar call.
How to Get SavedIn case you missed that, an altar call is a technique that was made quite popular during the Second Great Awakening (1790-1850) by the famed evangelist Charles Finney. During a sermon, one which focuses heavily on either the crucifixion, the fire of hell, the sinful man or any combination thereof, the preacher invites those in need of repentance to leave their seats and walk to the front of the room where he is standing in order to get saved. Most modern versions involve a preliminary raising of hands among closed eyes before the actual invitation is given. It is a very emotional moment and I must admit I have walked my share of aisles in an effort to restore myself.
Once those who are down front have met with counselors and prayed, the band kicks back into high gear. Before leaving they tell us that we are the best audience they have ever played to and I, for one, believe them. They were, without a doubt, the biggest Christian rock band of my youth. That is until three young men from Liberty University arrived on BET with a little video known as “Heavenbound.” For the next couple of years I became a disciple of the Christian rock scene, always trying to convince my secular music friends that dc Talk, The Newsboys, and Whitecross, were every bit as good as The Spin Doctors, Scarface, and Crash Test Dummies. Of course I could find a little acceptance with a few of the crossover artists such as Amy Grant or Michael W. Smith, but by the time they reached mainstream radio, my father discovered the writings of a man named Jeff Godwin.
InstabilityGodwin was the author of several anti-rock books published by the infamous Chick Publications. His most well known work was
What’s Wrong With Christian Rock? Once the UPS guy dropped off ten copies of this little gem at our front door, my life would never be the same. I arrived home one day to find every cassette and VHS tape owned by the Reynolds family had been boxed up and “victoriously” tossed into our dumpster (why we had our own personal dumpster will be covered later.) Dress codes quickly changed and for the next several months I lived in adolescent misery. Then, out of nowhere, random Christian Rock cassettes (and eventually CDs) would show up in the tape player of our van. I had hoped that the last episode of my father impersonating the prophet Elijah on Mt. Carmel had been a passing phase but that was not the case. Just as I began to settle with the idea that I could be a somewhat normal Christian teenager, the bottom dropped out. This cycle continued for the rest of my teens until I finally moved out. I’m not sure why my father just couldn’t decide what version of a “Christian family” he wanted to be. I would have gladly settled for stability, to the left or to the right, but even that was too much to ask for. For as soon as we would establish ourselves at one church, they would suddenly become too liberal…or too legalistic…or they supported the Disney corporation (remind me to tell you the story of the day we packed up every video, book, or item that was of Walt Disney and mailed it to our local newspaper in protest of Gay Day. Thank-you, Dr. James Dobson.)
Some HistoryDuring the late 70s and most of the 80s, there was a movement specifically targeting the notion of Rock n Roll music for Jesus. The roots of this movement date back to 1966 when John Lennon, in a typical overstatement, declared The Beatles “more popular than Jesus Christ.” Infuriated affiliates of the Bible Belt took to burning albums by the truckload. On an interesting side note, one of the biggest groups to speak out against The Beatles and rock music in general was the Ku Klux Klan. Thus a new form of transgression was born out of this dichotomy and united the famed unholy trinity of sex, drugs and rock n roll. It wasn’t long before rock music began finding its way into the sermons of evangelicals who, though well meaning, would inadvertently paint some very unflattering caricatures of Christianity in general. It didn’t help matters much that around this time, trends in rock were veering toward much heavier and darker tones which only contributed further to theories of rock n roll as a portal into Satanism. Rumors of backmasking, a technique where sound clips are inserted backwards into music tracks in order to reach the listener’s sub-conscious added to the hype. Renowned fundamentalists such as Bill Gothard and Bob Larson began writing articles and holding anti-rock seminars geared toward youth. In 1973, Dorothy Retallack gained notoriety for her experiments involving houseplants and their negative response to music by Led Zeppelin and Jimi Hendrix. Another story that began to circulate church circles was that of missionaries, claiming to have their children rebuked by recently converted tribesmen for listening to “drum beats” that were used to call up demons. It was becoming clear that Rock n Roll was not going to have an easy time in old-line churches. On the west coast however, the Jesus Movement was gaining momentum. Former hippies, who had little use for doctrinal wrangles, were “turning on” to the pacifism and love offered by Jesus. Rock n Roll was not only embraced, but was becoming an integral part of church services. Before long, the first members of Jesus Music were beginning to gain momentum, including Larry Norman, Keith Green, Randy Stonehill, and Phil Keaggy. Needless to say, they were not always welcomed with open arms. Norman only added fuel to the fire when he released his defiant, “Why Should the Devil Have All the Good Music?”
EvangelismOne of the first “Christian Rock” bands to appear around this time was founded by Ohio native, Bob Hartman. With their first release, Petra drew comparisons in style to The Eagles and The Allman Brothers Band. Though only met with moderate success throughout the 70s, the next two decades would solidify Petra’s place as Christian rocks biggest act as they would gain acceptance among youth looking for a sound that was not only mainstream, but allowed by their parents as well. Christian Rock gained ground when the focus shifted toward evangelism. A Christian Rock concert wasn’t just a safe place to drop your kids off; it was a battlefield for the souls of unsaved youth. Soon it was common for bands to be accompanied by youth pastors who would bring a gospel message to every show. In a way, the Great Commission was a justification for the worldy style. As Christian Rock surged in popularity, so did the other genres of music willing to profess Jesus within their lyrics. Soon, Heavy Metal, Rap, and Country were categories at the Dove Awards, the Gospel Music Association’s answer to the Grammys and the inevitable began to take shape.
Crossing OverIn the early 90s, a young woman by the name of Amy Grant was enjoying her place as CCM’s (Contemporary Christian Music is much friendlier than Christian Rock) first lady. The album,
Unguarded, spawned her first mainstream hit with “Find a Way.” In 1991,
Heart in Motion hit the airwaves and whatever Christian college swear word you can come up with hit the fan. While the tracks on the album focused more on relationships between men and women rather than “JC”, it was the music videos that really set off the alarms. In some sequences, Grant playfully dances with a man who is clearly not Gary Chapman, or Vince Gill for that matter. Thus the term “cross-over” became a negative term in some circles.
Heart in Motion went on to sell 5 million copies, unheard of in the Christian music industry. While Amy Grant was holding her own, label mate Michael W. Smith was making his run at super stardom as well. Having struck platinum once with the single, "Place in This World”, Smitty was ready to once again bridge the gap with his sixth studio release,
Change Your World. Not everyone was unhappy with the cross-over phenomenon. A lot of kids who were restricted to only what was sold at

Christian bookstores were finally able own albums that were played on the radio. Of
Change Your World, CCM reviewer Chris Well wrote “Here's an album by a Christian that you can play for any of your friends.” Another modification noticeable within the industry was the lack of “Jesus’ per minute” within songs by artist who had always been explicit of their intentions. Now it seemed as if many of the lyrics dedicated to Jesus, Lord, and Creator had been replaced by slick pronouns, almost like a girlfriend song for God. To add further confusion to the situation, some mainstream bands were releasing material that was oddly Christian in nature. In 1987, Irish rockers U2 released
The Joshua Tree, an album that was actually #6 on
CCM Magazine’s list and later book titled
The 100 Greatest Christian Albums of All Time. All in all, once the dust had settled, both Grant and Smith moved sheepishly back to their comfort zones to reign once again within CCM.
Safe AlternativesThe 90s were good to CCM and two names that were responsible for this were dc Talk and Jars of Clay. dc Talk, broke into the market as a response to the increased popularity of Rap. Oddly enough, two thirds of the band are white. As tastes evolved, dc Talk developed their style into more of a modern rock sound, the culmination of this being their 1995 release,
Jesus Freak. At a time when most of America had their eye on the Pacific Northwest for the next big thing, many comparisons were drawn in relation to bands like Pearl Jam, Nirvana, and Alice in Chains even though only two tracks on
Jesus Freak remotely resemble the Seattle Sound. Besides resurgence in flannel, another trend spurred on by the Grunge movement was the return of the acoustic guitar. The 80s had been split pretty even between hair bands and pop. The 90s welcomed a return to more roots type music with artists like REM, The Wallflowrs and Hootie and the Blowfish. In 1993, Nirvana raised the bar further with their live release,
Unplugged in New York. At Greenville College, another band was making use the acoustic renaissance along with sampled drums and the music department’s string section. Jars of Clay released their self titled debut within weeks of
Jesus Freak and oddly enough, had enormous cross-over success with the single, “Flood” on modern rock radio. Sixpence None the Richer also found mainstream success when the wistful, “Kiss Me” was included in the film,
She’s All That. As CCM was becoming a major player within the music industry, (at one point matching Country music in terms of sales) it was also becoming more and more acceptable as an alternative form of entertainment. Christian bookstores began to hang posters near the music section, listing secular artists along side their supposed “Christian counterpart.” For example, if you like The Dave Matthews Band, then you will also like Steven Curtis Chapman or if Pearl Jam is your thing then Third Day is the way to go. And just as it was at it’s pinnacle, it all began to slide downhill.
We Are NOT a Christian BandIt stands to some irony that the only Grammy the King of Rock n Roll ever received was for his Gospel releases. U2 was able to keep their following despite their religious inclinations. Even prog-rock veterans Kansas had brought issues of faith to the forefront of their music. During the turn of the millennium, spiritual talk was surfacing within the industry; most prevalent of this was in the Hard Rock genre. Though time and again the lead singers of their bands were firm in their denial of being associated with anything CCM, their lyrics were hard to ignore.
My soul cries for deliverance
Will I be denied
Christ
Tourniquet
My suicide Evanescence, “Tourniquet” from
FallenI hear a thunder in the distance
See a vision of a cross
I feel the pain that was given
On that sad day of lossCreed, “My Own Prison” from
My Own PrisonYou are the light
To my soul
You are my purpose
You’re everythingLifehouse, “Everything” from
No Name FaceThis strategy eventually rubbed off on a few bands who had been touring the Christian market for years. Switchfoot was another “dime a dozen” punk band with three releases from Sparrow records before their music was used in the film,
A Walk to Remember. Their release,
The Beautiful Letdown featured the smash hits, “Dare You to Move” and “Meant to Live” and much like Jars of Clay, Switchfoot was thrust into the mainstream spotlight and overnight they were the biggest name in Christian music. Unfortunately for CCM fans, lead singer John Foreman was not happy with his crown. During interviews, he began to emphatically deny the Christian tendencies of his lyrics, stating that they were still open to interpretation. In a further snub to the Christian music proper, Switchfoot was suspiciously absent from the 2005 Dove Awards even though they had several nominations and even won Artist of the Year. Seeing the success of
The Beautiful Letdown, many other artist tried their hand at mainstream breakthrough, though not with near the desired results. By this time, the generation that had taken its stance against the evils of rock music had all but faded into the shadows. Gone were the days of awkward altar calls and preachy hair bands. Most parents were becoming indifferent as to what music their children listened to, be it Christian or secular and thus, Christian Rock was no longer an umbrella that anyone saw the need to raise. Without souls to save or children to shelter, CCM needed to find new purpose. And find it they did.
Come, Now is the Time to WorshipFrom the very first days of the Jesus People, the blending of sacred and secular music for church services was imperative. Within the Jesus Movement, when an acid freak would come out of their addiction, rather than cut out their personality along with the old self, there was a sort of re-imagination of the soul that took place. If you painted before, you painted for Jesus now. If you played guitar, you played for the Lord and His Church. If you were a hooker or a Satanist, you went on a speaking tour. Hold that thought.
This is how modern worship music was born. We had the Psalms. There were 150 of them and they worked out fine. After Jesus left the Middle East and returned to the streets of heaven, the church aligned itself with Rome, which eventually became the Catholic Church. A lot of monks had a lot of time on their hands and so they wrote a lot of chants. There were passed onto priests who kept it real by singing the mass in Latin, i.e., the Kyrie, the Gloria, the Sanctus, etc, etc. After Martin Luther split off, he decided that the common people should bring it back down by singing as a congregation so he wrote songs for congregational singing, many based on old tavern standards. For the next 450 years, all sorts of composers contributed hymns to the church including Bach, Beethoven, Charles Wesley, John Newton, Fanny J. Crosby, Phillip Bliss, and George Beverly Shea. For the most part, there was very little change in the structure of hymns. Written almost exclusively in four-part harmony and scattered with deep theological teachings, the family hymnal was nearly as precious as the family Bible. During the Second Great Awakening, evangelists introduced another form of music known as gospel. Inspired in part by the old Negro spirituals, gospel music was much more emotional than a hymn and much simpler at that. When Jesus music began to spread in the 1970s, anyone who could pick up a guitar was viewed as contributing to the tradition that dated back to the time of David. As CCM gained in popularity, many of it’s artists contributed to this tradition as well. Sandi Patti released the popular “How Majestic is Your Name” while pre-crossover Amy Grant wowed the church with Rich Mullins’ “Sing Your Praise to the Lord.” Mullins had a massive hit himself with “Awesome God” which became the most sung “modern day hymn” in the American Church during the 1980s. As worship music (also referred to as Praise Music) became increasingly desirable, a few acts would try their hand at releasing entire albums for congregational singing. Petra was the first Christian Rock band to release the modern equivalent of a worship album with their bold,
The Rock Cries Out. The tracks from this album eventually became commonplace at youth groups across the world. 2000 saw this method explode as virtually every CCM artist released a worship album in some form. Two of the most successful of these were
Offerings by Third Day and
Worship by Michael W. Smith, back in the Christian zone for good. The movement has become such a force that some artists have resigned themselves to just writing and performing worship music. In fact, in some ways they have become the biggest names in Christian music and all without crossing over (ah, how times change). Hillsong United began to acquire a following when Darlene Zschech released her global phenomenon, “Shout to the Lord.” More recently they have solidified their place in the industry with “Mighty to Save.” Louie Giglio and his Passion members have had more than their share of achievement as artists such as Chris Tomlin, David Crowder, Matt Redman, Steve Fee, and Charlie Hall, have been models of structure as practically every church on the planet seems to be adding a Contemporary service. As for the Christian music industry, it seems to have taken a bit of a nosedive. After 30 years,
CCM Magazine released its final issue as sales and interest have been declining. Groups who once sold out arenas are retuning to clubs and churches. And yet, the music has found its purpose within the service of the Church, as it began in storefronts all those years ago.
Wrapping UpSo here I am, more or less a product of all of that. Looking back over my formidable years it seems pretty trivial to have made such a fuss over it. After all, it’s only music, and some pretty shoddy music at that. It seems like Christian Rock was sort of a flash in the pan that had its 30 years of fame and then it was gone. We’ve all moved on. I rarely spin my I-Pod near anything remotely resembling CCM. If anything I’ll throw on some worship music but there’s only so much of that I can take. The other day, Laura and I were out for dinner when I suddenly had the urge to relive some of my youth. Landing on Petra, I pulled up their worship album. My wife is now hooked on the 1989 cut, “King of Kings.” She says it makes her want to get out there and run. The other morning she was listening to it before school while I was still asleep.
I like to hear her sing. After all, that’s what the music is there for.